Tiny Things I Hate: The Way Spin Magazine Describes Songs They Think You Should Listen ToIn every issue, Spin includes a list of 10 songs that they recommend with a very quick description. One would assume that if you were recommending a song, you would describe it in such a way that the reader might be able to tell if it would be something they'd like. You'd try to place it in a genre or a combination of genres, you'd describe the sound stylistically, you'd name similar bands and artists, something like that.
Well, here are two descriptions that I grabbed randomly out of the issue I was reading when I decided to make this a TTIH:
Josh Reichmann Oracle Band - "Shivering Black" - "A stomping, sparkling sci-fi popscape that hits like a kiss from a starman you suspect is full of shit but still dig for his dance moves."
...um, what? What exactly is a popscape? Is a starman an astronaut? What is it like being kissed by an astronaut, and what does it SOUND like? What the hell does a starman sound like when he's full of shit? Is it different if I only SUSPECT he's full of shit?
And then...Florence and the Machine - "Dog Days Are Over" - "Florence Welch's clear, tuff-dart vocals are the killer constant as bedsit folk gives way to girl-group bomp, dissolves into ethereal Kate Bushisms, and ends on a romping rave-up."
Again, WHAT? Tuff-dart? Bedsit folk? Rave-up? I mean, maybe these things are words, but why do they have to be so pretentious about it? It's really off-putting and definitely not going to entice anybody to listen to the song. If you're trying to describe a song people don't know, you need to describe it as it relates to things people DO know. The "stomping, sparkling" bit from the first one is okay, it's a little purple but I think most people would get the general idea of what that means in regards to a song. And girl-group bomp, that works, people can figure that out. But half the time these things read like there's some sort of contest at Spin headquarters to see who can cram the most metaphors into a 30 word description, and you get bonus points for every obscure music reference you make. Not that I'm calling Kate Bush obscure, but other descriptions make a lot of weird references. If you want to compare to another band/artist, compare to Bowie or Dylan or the Stones, not Godspeed You! Black Emperor.